Why is Jeff Sessions staying on as Attorney General? Why did Hope Hicks choose to leave?
The answer is pretty clear to me… Jeff Sessions is staying on because his remaining as Attorney General annoys the hell out of Donald Trump. Hope Hicks left because she felt the impending legal exposure of working with a President who lies.
Initially, Jeff Sessions thought he and Trump could work together on developing a conservative agenda in the Justice Department. Jeff Sessions had one minor hiccup, he had to recuse himself from overseeing the Justice Department probe of the independent counsel, Robert Mueller, because Sessions had discussions with the Russians while working with the Trump Campaign. This was a completely appropriate decision.
Then, when Trump demeaned and humiliated Sessions over the recusal Session’s first response was to take offense at being publicly demeaned and humiliated by a boorish and ignorant Donald Trump, and Sessions offered his resignation.
However, Trump was persuaded by those around him not to accept the resignation because of “obstruction of justice” concerns if Sessions was “fired” in order for Trump to gain more control over the “independent” counsel investigation (plus there would be extremely messy confirmation hearings for a new appointee). Look what happened when Trump fired Comey… things got worse for Trump.
Sessions was persuaded by others to stay through appeals to the importance of creating a conservative agenda in the Justice Department, and appeals to his conservative principles of what he could accomplish persuaded him to stay on.
But why does he continue to stay?
Because Jeff Sessions is furious with Trump. He hates Trump. If he leaves, that will please Donald Trump. If he stays, that annoys and irritates the dickens out of Donald Trump.
What’s the best way for Jeff Sessions to get back at Donald Trump? By staying on as the Attorney General. That irritates the hell out of Donald Trump every single day. Why do you think Sessions had dinner (photographed) with Ron Rosenstein? That was no accident. Sessions is enjoying annoying the hell out of Trump.
If I were Robert Mueller I’d see if I could get Sessions to wear a concealed wire and have him go talk with Trump about ending the investigation of independent counsel Robert Mueller (obstruction of justice). I bet Sessions would consider it.
Sessions (the Attorney General; chief law enforcement officer) wears a wire and has a private meeting with the President… one simple question from Sessions to the President…
Sessions: “Mr President, would you like me to end the independent counsel investigation in order to protect you?”
Trump’s such an irrational impulsive idiot he’ll say, “Yes. Absolutely. End the investigation.”
So Sessions is staying on as Attorney General exactly because it pisses off Donald Trump no end. The more it irritates Donald Trump, the happier it makes Jeff Sessions.
Why did Hope Hicks choose to leave?
Because she feels the pressure of her legal exposure. Trump lies. Hicks knows she’s involved in the lie created when Donald Trump dictated the response to the Russian meeting with Trump Jr., Manafort, and Kushner (a meeting Trump knew about and approved). She knows she has to tell the truth to the FBI and she knows this exposes her to “conspiracy” to obstruct justice charges (and possibly more violations of additional laws, such as violations of federal election laws).
Hope Hicks felt the pressure of her own legal exposure. She can’t lie to the FBI (never-ever lie to the FBI), but if she tells the truth she’s in big-big legal trouble.
In the midst of this emotional stress and pressure, her boyfriend in the White House, Rob Porter, becomes embroiled in a controversy surrounding his past marriages. In an impulsive emotional decision she wrote a press response defending Porter (who represents an important source of emotional support for her).
But that only created more stress for her as the allegations against Porter were substantiated with photographs of his ex-wife with a black eye.
Hope Hicks is feeling the stress, particularly the stress of her legal exposure. She can’t think straight or function in her job because she is always thinking and worrying about her legal exposure. She decided to resign because she is seeking some degree of emotional peace, and separation from Trump and the White House is the only way she’s going to find it.
Mueller should consider also asking Hope Hicks to wear a wire and talk to Trump about their past involvement in colluding with the Russians.
Should I stay or should I go now? If I stay there will be trouble. If I go it will be double.
The Clash
Craig Childress, Psy.D.
Clinical Psychologist, PSY 18857